How to Choose a Protein Powder — And Why Whole Foods Should Always Come First
- Katrin Peo
- Nov 12
- 4 min read
Why Whole Foods Should Always Come First?
Your body doesn’t just need protein — it needs the nutrients that come with it. Whole-food protein sources like fish, eggs, lean meats, legumes, tofu, tempeh, Greek yogurt, nuts, seeds offer a complex package of amino acids, vitamins, minerals, fibre, and beneficial compounds that work together to support overall health.
Protein powders, on the other hand, are isolated, processed fractions of food. While they can help meet daily protein targets, they lack the nutrient density, natural food matrix, and synergy found in real foods.
According to nutrition scientists at ZOE, many people in industrialised countries already consume enough protein through everyday foods. The growing market of “high-protein” shakes and bars is often driven by marketing rather than biological need. ZOE’s experts, including Prof. Tim Spector and Dr. Sarah Berry, note that protein-fortified products like bars or shakes are typically ultra-processed, often containing added sugars, emulsifiers, or artificial sweeteners that can negatively impact the gut microbiome and overall metabolic health.
👉 You can read more on this topic in ZOE’s science-based article on protein bars.
Whole-food proteins also provide micronutrients (like magnesium, zinc, and B-vitamins) that powders don’t — supporting bone, brain, hormonal, and immune health. And because real foods digest more gradually, they promote steadier energy and blood-sugar balance.
In short: real food first. Use a protein powder only as a supplement when your daily schedule, activity level, or age makes it hard to meet protein needs from meals alone.
When Protein Powders Might Make Sense
You might consider adding a protein powder if you:
Have a very busy lifestyle or travel frequently
Train hard regularly and need post-workout recovery support
Are going through perimenopause or menopause and want to make sure you preserve muscle mass next to regular physical exercise
Follow a vegan diet and find it difficult to reach protein goals from food alone
Even then — remember: protein powders should complement, not replace, your meals.
Animal vs Plant Protein: Which Is Better?
Animal-Based Proteins (Whey, Casein, Beef Isolate, Egg White)
Contain all essential amino acids, including leucine, key for muscle synthesis.
Backed by solid research — a large meta-analysis (Morton et al., Br J Sports Med., 2018) showed that protein supplementation supports muscle growth and strength during resistance training.
Whey isolate is low in lactose and typically well-tolerated.
🌱 Plant-Based Proteins (Pea, Rice, Soy, Hemp, Pumpkin, Blends)
Sustainable, allergen-friendly, and suitable for vegan diets.
Blends (like pea + rice) can achieve a complete amino acid profile.
However, plant powders are often more processed and more prone to heavy-metal contamination, since crops absorb lead or cadmium from soil.
The Question of “Clean”: What to Watch For
1. Heavy Metals and Contaminants
The Clean Label Project Protein Study 2.0 found that:
Nearly half of the tested protein powders contained measurable levels of lead, cadmium, arsenic, or mercury.
Plant-based powders had about 5 × more cadmium than whey.
Chocolate-flavoured powders were most contaminated, because cocoa naturally pulls lead and cadmium from soil.
Independent analyses by Consumer Reports and Harvard Health have echoed these concerns. Always check whether the brand provides third-party testing, publishes lab results, or holds certifications like NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Choice, or Clean Label Project Purity Award.
For a related read, see my blog post: 👉 Energy and Protein Bars — Are They Really Healthy?
2. Flavouring and Additives
Unflavoured or vanilla-flavoured powders are generally the cleanest choice. Chocolate versions often contain cocoa (a potential source of heavy metals) and extra sweeteners.
Avoid:
Artificial sweeteners like sucralose and acesulfame-K
Emulsifiers and thickeners such as polysorbates or carrageenan
“Natural and artificial flavours” or unnecessary stabilisers
If you’d like to learn more about sweeteners and their effects, check out my article:
3. Ingredient Transparency
A short ingredient list is in general a better choice.
Better: Whey protein isolate, natural vanilla flavour
Worse: Whey concentrate, cocoa blend, sugar, artificial flavours, sucralose, soy lecithin
How Much Protein Do You Really Need?
According to the British Journal of Sports Medicine meta-analysis (Morton et al., 2018), more isn’t always better: Up to 1.6 g protein per kg body weight per day is sufficient for muscle growth and recovery.
For most active adults, that’s roughly:
90–120 g protein/day for women (60–75 kg)
110–150 g/day for men (70–95 kg)
You can read more about protein in my blog:
Checklist for Choosing a Protein Powder
Prioritise whole-food protein first.
Choose unflavoured or vanilla versions of protein powders when possible.
Avoid artificial sweeteners and long ingredient lists.
Look for third-party testing (NSF, Informed Choice, Clean Label Project). It's important to note here, that though the protein powders mentioned on Clean Label Project page are heavy-metal free, several of them contain artificial sweeteners and emulsifiers. Therefore it's always important to read the product label when purchasing the protein powder.
Rotate brands occasionally to reduce exposure to potential contaminants.
Keep total protein intake in balance — powders are supplements, not staples.
Take-Home Message
Protein powders can be practical, but they’re not a substitute for a balanced, whole-food diet. The cleanest protein supplement is one that’s simple, third-party tested, and used in moderation — not as a meal replacement, but as a helpful backup.
When you focus on real food first and choose tested, minimal-ingredient powders only when necessary, you support both your short-term fitness goals and long-term health.
References
ZOE: The Science of Protein Bars — Are They Actually Healthy?
Clean Label Project: Protein Study 2.0 (2024)
Elchemy: Toxic Ingredients to Avoid in Protein Powders (2025)
Healthline (2025): Protein Powders and Heavy Metals
Harvard Health (2022): The Hidden Dangers of Protein Powders
If you want to change your nutrition to be more healthy, balanced- supporting your health goals, then don't hesitate to reach out to me for personalised nutrition counselling at info@katrinpeo.com.
Comments